Data centres and AI - Need to Know: Updated Tuesday 17 November
With increasing use of AI (artificial intelligence) huge growth in data centres is predicted. Data centres are major users of energy and water, as well as producing noise and light. Many people are objecting and calling for a moratorium on new data centres and extensions of existing ones.
Our U3A group held a forum on this topic on Monday 16th November, led by Dr Sarah Webber from Melbourne University.
Preliminary notes from our forum are below and more information will be added in later posts, as this is an ongoing topic for climate action.
Background
Some background information is available here from the Climate Council.
There has also been widespread publicity about residents successfully objecting to the extension of a data centre in Footscray.
As well the climate and energy implications outlined by the Climate Council, there are also social and environmental implications. Data centres are often large industrial buildings, which emit constant ambient noise and light, including at night. There are also concerns about dust, air pollution and loss of home value.
We are now in the election period in Victoria and we may wish to ask what our candidates are proposing to do about data centres, as well as ask about federal government proposals.
With the increasing use of AI, data centres are predicted to grow enormously. The two topics are connected and it is important to think critically about AI as well. AI is being heavily promoted but we need to recognise not only the risks from AI use, but also that a lot of money has been invested in its development, and there are huge vested interests trying to promote it to us.
Notes from the forum
Sarah provided further information on data centres. (These are my notes which may not be totally correct but hopefully not too far off the mark!)
Data centres can range in size from small fairly inconspicuous buildings, such as several Telstra centres in the city, to very large industrial scale buildings.
They house servers which are used for many purposes including email, web services, and apps, including everyday apps that many of us may use for banking, utilities and so on.
Some organisations have their own servers but others may rent from specialist data centres like NextDC. Organisational standards may vary.
The actions we use our devices for are increasingly happening through these servers (these are the actual 'cloud') rather than on the devices.
The growing use of so-called artificial intelligence (AI) is increasing the demand for data centres greatly. Many are planned or in development in Victoria.
AI is basically 'Large Language Models' (LLMs) which have been trained on all the information on the internet and can make predictive statements. They are becoming increasingly good at answering queries but can still make information up ('hallucinate') or produce incorrect information.
With increasing use of normal tech and LLMs, data centres are requiring increasing amounts of energy (as well as water for cooling) and some can use as much energy as some towns. Even when they propose to use renewable energy it is actually difficult or unlikely that they can do so completely and most have diesel generators which add to the noise and air pollution caused by the centres.
There is much more information which I will try to cover in later posts but we were also interested in what we can do.
What can we do?
We can support a moratorium on further data centres until better regulation and guidelines are in place, and we can contact candidates in our electorates to see if they will support a moratorium.
We can advocate for better regulated use of technology and LLMs, including research and policy on what is actually useful and beneficial and what is wasteful and even socially and environmentally harmful.
We can look at our own use of data and internet, and try to minimize our use of the 'billionaire big tech' services which have so much power and influence over users.
Sarah and colleagues at Melbourne Uni and in the local group '
Merri-bek Tech' are looking at alternatives and can provide support. Check the link for more information if interested. There is a session coming up on 3rd December about 'getting off big tech'.
Sarah is also conducting an action research project which U3A members are invited to join - I will provide more information separately soon.
This has just been a quick update - there were many more topics covered and questions asked by group members (including about privacy concerns) which I will try to explore in more detail in later posts.
The picture below shows Google AI which automatically appears when you do a Google search - just one example of the way AI/LLMs are being pushed now. There alternative ways of searching that don't do this, (and also protect privacy) including DuckDuckGo and StartPage - you can learn more about these through Merri-bek Tech.
 |
Search engines push us to use AI - but what are the costs? |